Best Places to Eat in Cedarburg, Wisconsin

Check out many delicious options in this small town

Published: June 18, 2023

Cedarburg, Wisconsin, is renowned for its charming downtown, full of unique shops and eateries that provide visitors with a one-of-a-kind experience. From elegant restaurants to cozy pubs, Cedarburg has many options – whether you’re looking for a romantic dinner or an evening out with friends. With so many delicious options in this small town, it can be difficult to decide where to eat while visiting Cedarburg. Hopefully, this blog post helps you narrow down your choices so you know where to eat next time.


Brandywine is the perfect spot for a romantic dinner. Featuring a delicious menu of fresh seafood, steaks, and American favorites, this charming restaurant also offers outdoor seating for those warm summer nights. The wine list is extensive, and the attentive service keeps people coming back time and again. Be sure to save room for dessert – with delectable treats like homemade cheesecake and chocolate mousse, you won’t be able to resist. In addition, the place is easy to find since it’s downtown and near other town amenities.

Galioto’s Twelve21

Galioto’s Twelve21 in Cedarburg, Wisconsin, is a popular restaurant that serves classic Italian dishes and delicious pizza. The restaurant has been around for years, making it a favorite spot for locals and visitors alike. The menu at Galioto’s Twelve21 is vast, offering everything from traditional favorites like pasta and pizza to more unique creations such as their prosciutto-and-fig pizza. At Galioto’s Twelve21, the staff is passionate about their work and dedicated to serving memorable meals.

The Farmstead

The Farmstead is a local favorite in Cedarburg, Wisconsin, offering classic American fare. The restaurant is located in an old farmhouse that has been restored and decorated with country charm. The spacious outdoor patio overlooks a pond and offers spectacular views of the countryside. Inside, guests enjoy cozy dining areas filled with comfy seating next to crackling fireplaces. The menu consists of classic American dishes such as burgers, sandwiches, steaks, ribs, and other hearty entrees.

Lime Cantina

Lime Cantina in Cedarburg, Wisconsin, is a lively and vibrant Mexican restaurant and bar that offers a unique atmosphere. The restaurant’s interior is decorated with bright colors, authentic artwork, and festive décor. Its menu focuses on traditional Mexican dishes made from fresh, locally sourced ingredients. Lime Cantina also offers an extensive selection of tequilas, margaritas, sangrias, and craft beers. In addition, the restaurant features nightly specials and happy hour deals.

Settlers Inn

Settlers Inn is another popular food spot in Cedarburg, Wisconsin, known for its delicious and hearty American cuisine. The restaurant’s interior features a charming rustic atmosphere, with vintage furniture and decorations, giving off a warm and inviting feeling as soon as you step inside. The menu at Settlers Inn offers an array of mouthwatering dishes, from light salads to juicy steaks and burgers. For starters, try the warm baked brie topped with candied walnuts and honey. For your main entree, you can enjoy a classic burger, mac n’ cheese dish, or one of their signature seafood dishes.

Other Things to Do in Cedarburg, WI:

Table Of Contents